Natureza & Conservação Natureza & Conservação
Nat Con 2016;14:137-41 DOI: 10.1016/j.ncon.2016.06.002
Policy Forums
Environmental licensing on rhodolith beds: insights from a worm
Cinthya Simone Gomes Santosa, Jaqueline Barreto Linob, Priscila de Cerqueira Verasb,c, Gilberto Menezes Amado-Filhod, Ronaldo Bastos Francini-Filhoe, Fabio Santos Mottab, Rodrigo Leão de Mouraf, Guilherme Henrique Pereira-Filhob,,
a Department of Marine Biology, Institute of Biology, Universidade Federal Fluminense, Niterói, RJ, Brazil
b Instituto do Mar, Laboratory of Marine Ecology and Conservation, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Santos, SP, Brazil
c Center for Natural and Human Sciences, Universidade Federal do ABC, São Bernardo do Campo, SP, Brazil
d Instituto de Pesquisas Jardim Botânico do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
e Department of Engineering and Environment, Universidade Federal da Paraíba, Rio Tinto, PB, Brazil
f Institute of Biology, Laboratório de Sistemas Avançados de Gestão da Produção (SAGE), Instituto Alberto Luiz Coimbra de Pós-Graduação e Pesquisa de Engenharia (COPPE), Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
Received 12 January 2016, Accepted 07 June 2016
Abstract

Rhodoliths are free-living nodules formed by crustose coralline algae that promote multi-dimensional microhabitats for a highly diverse community. Because their CaCO3 production, rhodolith beds constitute areas of interest for mining activities. On the other hand, other goods and services provided by these environments such as nurseries habitats, fishing and climate regulation remain undersized. Besides directly CaCO3 exploitation, these diverse ecosystems within the Brazilian economic exclusive zone are often covering potentially sites for oil and gas extraction. The IBAMA (Environmental Agency of the Brazilian government) have been applying the precautionary principle to deny requests for oil/gas drilling activities where rhodolith beds occur. Here, we discuss recent data about diversity associated with rhodoliths and also record the “rare” worm Nuchalosyllis cf. maiteae. More than the distribution of one only species, our finding is an emblematic example of our infancy knowledge state about diversity associated with rhodolith beds in southwestern Atlantic. We argue that these knowledge is still insufficient to subside any attempt in classify priorities areas for oil wells drilling. In addition, we claim that the precautionary principle adopted by IBAMA must prevalence until we have robust data allowing predictions concerning higher or lower biodiversity associated with rhodolith beds.

Keywords
Marine diversity, Maerl, Mesophotic reefs, Crustose coralline algae

Rhodoliths are free-living calcareous nodules built mainly by crustose coralline algae. They occur worldwide and may form large beds that cover huge expanse of tropical, temperate, and even polar shelves, providing multi-dimensional hard microhabitats for diverse biological communities (Foster et al., 2013). Because of their huge CaCO3 accumulation, rhodolith beds constitute areas of great interest for carbonates’ mining that supplies agricultural and industrial applications (Amado-Filho et al., 2012a; Moura et al., 2013). While rhodolith beds are largely and mistakenly seen as mineral resources, the ecosystem services they provide, such as fishing and climate regulation, are grossly underrated in environmental impact assessments (Amado-Filho and Pereira-Filho, 2012). In Brazil, the country with the world's largest rhodolith beds, extraction of up to 18t/companyyear−1 may be regularly licensed by IBAMA, the Federal Environmental Licensing Agency (Instrução Normativa 89, Feb. 02, 2006). Although sub-surface rhodoliths are often alive and definitely harbor high marine biodiversity, the Brazilian law refers to them as non-living marine resources, with exploratory regulations established by the National Mining Department (Departamento Nacional de Produção Mineral – DNPDM). Moreover, rhodolith beds overlap with several oil and gas fields within the Brazilian Economic Exclusive Zone (EEZ). The building of new infrastructure in such areas has been recently restricted by IBAMA, based on the Precautionary Principle – a fundamental tool for countering the chronic overlook of scientific uncertainties in an unscientific manner (Cooney, 2004). Despite recent progress (e.g., Riul et al., 2009; Amado-Filho et al., 2010; Bahia et al., 2010; Brasileiro et al., 2015), knowledge about the distribution and biodiversity associated with rhodolith beds in Brazil is still fragmented and incomplete, impeding thorough environmental impact assessments of the steadily growing industrial activities. Paradoxically, uncertainties in predicting environmental impacts have been evoqued by economic groups as a reason for the approval of mining licenses (Cooney, 2004). Once rhodolith beds cover extensive areas of the Brazilian EEZ (Fig. 1A), large-scale mining and hydrocarbon's exploitation are indeed an imminent threat with yet unpredictable consequences. Here, while recording the occurrence of the “rare genus” Nuchalosyllis (Polychaeta) in the Fernando de Noronha Archipelago (FNA), we emphasize the major knowledge gaps about the biodiversity associated to Brazilian rhodolith beds, and the consequences for environmental licensing.

Fig. 1.

Sampling localities for all known specimens of Nuchalosyllis. (A) Fernando de Noronha Archipelago (detail). Light brown patches indicate areas where rhodolith beds have been mapped (Gherardi, 2004; Pascelli et al., 2013; Amado-Filho et al., 2007; Amado-Filho et al., 2010; Villas-Boas et al., 2013; Pereira-Filho et al., 2012; Amado-Filho et al., 2012a; Bahia et al., 2010; Riul et al., 2009; Testa and Bosence, 1999; Amado-Filho et al., 2012b, respectively from south to north). Blue arrows indicate localities of the two known Nuchalosyllis species, (Fukuda and Nogueira, 2012; Rullier and Amoureux, 1979). Dark green arrow indicates the site where we sampled Nuchalosyllis at 40m depth. (B and C) Detail of rhodolith bed (Photos: Zaira Matheus).

Before our find (Fig. 1) (specimen deposited in MNRJP785), Nuchalosyllis maiteae was only known for the holotype (MZUSP 01016) collected at 75m depth offshore Rio de Janeiro State (Fukuda and Nogueira, 2012). Such as other known specie of the same genus, N. maiteae was initially obtained by ship-based dredging and grabbing. Despite being the tools used to provide most of the currently available biological data about rhodolith-associated biodiversity (Foster et al., 2013), dredging and grabbing are limited for sampling small invertebrates within rhodoliths’ microhabitats, especially the soft bodied, cryptic and infaunal species that can have significant roles in food web (Foster et al., 2013; Kenchington and Hutchings, 2012). Only recently the use of SCUBA has been recognized and established as a complimentary tool for sampling such soft-bodied infaunal species (Foster et al., 2013). For example, SCUBA-based assessments in California, USA, revealed eight species of cryptofaunal chitons, four of which were previously undescribed (Clark, 2000). Santos et al. (2011) also used SCUBA to sample honeycomb worms (Polychaeta: Sabellariidae), finding that six of the ten Sabellaria species known from Brazil occur associated with rhodolith beds, including a new species that is apparently restricted to rodoliths.

Despite the aforementioned value for comprehensive biodiversity assessments, SCUBA recreational standards limits sampling to <30m depths. Recently, we used mixed-gas (TRIMIX) and technical diving techniques to sample rhodolith beds in scattered continental and oceanic localities along the Brazilian coast (e.g. Pereira-Filho et al., 2012; Moura et al., 2013; Amado-Filho et al., 2016). Although we sampled only one specimen of N. cf. maiteae in the Fernando de Noronha Archipelago (i.e.; >2000km from the type and only known locality) (Figs. 1 and 2), it is possible to hypothesized that the distribution of this taxon is much wider than previously known, and that sampling effort is insufficient to any comprehensive understanding about the biodiversity harbored by this habitat. More than an additional range extension record for one of hundreds of thousands “worm” species, N. maiteae is an emblematic example of the incipient knowledge about the biodiversity of Southwestern Atlantic rhodolith beds. Conversely, research and discovery of hydrocarbon exploitation fields rapidly increased in the last decade, especially in the mesophotic habitats of this region (e.g., Moura et al., 2013), many of those in rhodolith beds such as Peregrino oil field, Campos Basin (Tâmega et al., 2013, 2014), the area where N. maiteae was discovered. Offshore drilling increases the concentration of suspended particles (Patin, 1999), with well-established negative effects over the health of crustose coralline algae (e.g., Reynier et al., 2015) and community-wide changes from sedimentation and contamination (Patin, 1999).

Fig. 2.

Nuchalosyllis cf. maiteae. (A) Anterior end, dorsal view. (B) Parapodia 15, posterior view; (C) detail of dorsal cirri with dark red inclusions; (D) Chaetae heterogomph falciger from parapodia 15; (E) Chaetae heterogomph falciger from parapodia 41; (F) parapodia 41, posterior view, dorsal cirri lost; (G) dorsal cirrophore with papillae. Papillae. Legends: ac., Acicula; cp., Cirrophore; pa., Papillae; pc., Peristomial cirri; vc., Ventral cirri. Scale: A. 0.8mm; B. 0.13mm; C. 0.25mm; D. 0.03mm; E. 0.03mm; F. 0.1mm; G. 0.08mm.

The term “rare species” is associated to low frequency and small population sizes (Cao et al., 1998). Even only two specimens of N. maiteae have been found up to date; the sampling effort is too limited to classify it or any other associated species as rare or abundant. Basic information about predictor variables of associated biodiversity is still lacking (e.g.; rhodolith size, volume, form, complexity and density). Rhodolith beds are extensive and heterogeneous habitats, and the small spatial scales within the nodules represent and additional challenge for designing comprehensive sampling programs to assess biodiversity patterns. However, considering the increased rates of anthropogenic disturbances (Broderick, 2015), it is clear that the timing needed for extensive sampling is not compatible with the speed at which important management decisions need to be taken (Kenchington and Hutchings, 2012).

While robust data on species’ occurrences and distribution patterns accumulate, and surrogates for biodiversity patterns are developed (Kenchington and Hutchings, 2012), the precautionary principle adopted by IBAMA must be consistently applied in order to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem services provided by rhodolith beds, as evidenced from recent data about macroalgae (Amado-Filho and Pereira-Filho, 2012), fishes (Simon et al., 2016) and the polychaete worm, N. maiteae recorded herein. Instead of pressing IBAMA for rapid licensing, the industries that affect rhodoliths and other megadiversity Brazilian marine ecosystems must, truly, engage in research and conservation initiatives that go beyond the immediate needs of individual exploitation projects.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

We thank the Fernando de Noronha Marine National Park staff for logistic support and research permits (SISBIO/34245-3). Financial support was provided by the Brazilian Research Council (CNPq; grant 484875/2011-6 to GHPF). GMAF, RBFF and RLM acknowledge grants from CNPq, CAPES, FAPERJ and Brasoil. PCV and JBL acknowledge their scholarships from Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP, processes 2013/26594-4 and 2015/15212-9, respectively).

References
Amado-Filho et al., 2007
G.M. Amado-Filho,G. Maneveldt,R.C.C. Manso
Structure of rhodolith beds from a depth gradient of 4 to 55meters at the south of Espírito Santo State coast, Brazil
Cienc. Marinas, 33 (2007), pp. 399-410
Amado-Filho et al., 2010
G.M. Amado-Filho,G.W. Maneveldt,G.H. Pereira-Filho
Seaweed diversity associated with a Brazilian tropical rhodolith bed
Cienc. Marinas, 36 (2010), pp. 371-391
Amado-Filho and Pereira-Filho, 2012
G.M. Amado-Filho,G.H. Pereira-Filho
Rhodolith beds in Brazil: a new potential habitat for marine bioprospection
Rev. Bras. Farmacogn., 22 (2012), pp. 782-788
Amado-Filho et al., 2012a
G.M. Amado-Filho,R.L. Moura,A.C. Bastos
Rhodolith A beds are major CaCO3 bio-factories in the tropical South West Atlantic
Amado-Filho et al., 2012b
G.M. Amado-Filho,G.H. Pereira-Filho,R.G. Bahia
Occurrence and distribution of rhodolith beds on the Fernando de Noronha Archipelago of Brazil
Aquat. Bot., 101 (2012), pp. 41-45
Amado-Filho et al., 2016
G.M. Amado-Filho,R.L. Moura,A.C. Bastos
Mesophotic ecosystems of the unique South Atlantic atoll are composed by rhodolith beds and scattered consolidated reefs
Bahia et al., 2010
R.G. Bahia,D.P. Abrantes,P.S. Brasileiro
Rhodolith bed structure along a depth gradient from northern coast of Bahia State, Brazil
Braz. J. Oceanogr., 58 (2010), pp. 323-337
Brasileiro et al., 2015
P.S. Brasileiro,G.H. Pereira-Filho,R.G. Bahia
Macroalgal composition and community structure of the largest rhodolit in the world
Mar. Biodivers., (2015), pp. 1-14
Broderick, 2015
A.C. Broderick
Grand challenges in marine conservation and sustainable use
Front. Mar. Sci., 2 (2015), pp. 1-13
Cao et al., 1998
Y. Cao,D. Williams,N.E. Williams
How important are rare species in aquatic community ecology and bioassessment?
Limnol. Oceanogr., 43 (1998), pp. 1403-1409
Clark, 2000
R.N. Clark
The chiton fauna of the Gulf of California rhodolith beds (with descriptions of four new species)
Nemouria – Occasional Papers of the Delaware Museum of Natural History, 43 (2000), pp. 1-20
Cooney, 2004
R. Cooney
The Precautionary Principle in Biodiversity Conservation and Natural Resource Management: An Issues Paper for Policy-makers, Researchers and Practitioners
IUCN, (2004)
51 pp.
Foster et al., 2013
M. Foster,G.M. Amado-Filho,N.A. Kamenos
39th ed., Smithsonian Institution Scholarly Press, (2013)pp. 143-156
Fukuda and Nogueira, 2012
M.V. Fukuda,J.M.M. Nogueira
On a new species of Nuchalosyllis (Polychaeta: Syllidae), a rare syllid genus only known from Brazilian waters
J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. U. K., 93 (2012), pp. 963-966
Gherardi, 2004
D.F.M. Gherardi
Community structure and carbonate production of a temperate rhodolith bank from Arvoredo Island, Southern Brazil
Braz. J. Oceanogr., 52 (2004), pp. 207-224
Kenchington and Hutchings, 2012
R. Kenchington,P. Hutchings
Science, biodiversity and Australian management of marine ecosystems
Ocean Coast. Manage., 69 (2012), pp. 194-199
Moura et al., 2013
R.L. Moura,N.A. Secchin,G.M. Amado-Filho
Spatial patterns of benthic megahabitats and conservation planning in the Abrolhos Bank
Cont. Shelf Res., 70 (2013), pp. 109-117
Pascelli et al., 2013
C. Pascelli,P. Riul,R. Riosmena-Rodríguez
Seasonal and depth-driven changes in rhodolith bed structure and associated macroalgae off Arvoredo island (Southeastern Brazil)
Aquat. Bot., 111 (2013), pp. 62-65
Patin, 1999
S. Patin
The Environmental Impact of the Offshore Oil and Gas Industry
Eco Monitor Publishing, (1999)
Pereira-Filho et al., 2012
G.H. Pereira-Filho,G.M. Amado-Filho,R.L. Moura
Extensive rhodolith beds cover the summits of Southwestern Atlantic Ocean seamounts
J. Coast. Res., 279 (2012), pp. 261-269
Reynier et al., 2015
M. Reynier,F.T. Tâmega,S.D. Daflon
Long- and short-term effects of smothering and burial by drill cuttings on calcareous algae in a static-renewal test
Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 9999 (2015), pp. 1-6
Riul et al., 2009
P. Riul,P. Lacouth,P.R. Pagliosa
Rhodolith beds at the easternmost extreme of South America: community structure of an endangered environment
Aquat. Bot., 90 (2009), pp. 315-320
Rullier and Amoureux, 1979
F. Rullier,L. Amoureux
Campagne de la Calypso au large des côtes Atlantiques de l’Amérique du Sud (1961–1962). I. 33. Annélides Polychetes
Annales de l’Institut Oceanographique, 55 (1979), pp. 145-206
Santos et al., 2011
A.S. Santos,P. Riul,A.C.S. Brasil
Encrusting Sabellariidae (Annelida: Polychaeta) in rhodolith beds, with description of a new species of Sabellaria from Brazilian coast
J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. U. K., 91 (2011), pp. 425-438
(Special issue)
Simon et al., 2016
T. Simon,H.T. Pinheiro,R.L. Moura
Mesophotic fishes of the Abrolhos Shelf, the largest reef ecosystem in the South Atlantic
Tâmega et al., 2013
F.T.S. Tâmega,P. Spotorno-Oliveira,M.A.O. Figueiredo
Catalogue of the Benthic Marine Life From Peregrino Oil Field, Campos Basin, Brazil
Instituto Biodiversidade Marinha, (2013)pp. 140
Tâmega et al., 2014
F.T.S. Tâmega,D. Bassi,M.A.O. Figueiredo
Deep-water rhodolith bed from central Brazilian continental shelf, Campos Basin: Coralline algal and faunal taxonomic composition
J. Coral Reef Stud., 16 (2014), pp. 21-31
Testa and Bosence, 1999
V. Testa,D.W. Bosence
Physical and biological controls on the formation of carbonate and siliciclastic bedforms on the North-east Brazilian shelf
Sedimentology, 46 (1999), pp. 279-301
Villas-Boas et al., 2013
A.B. Villas-Boas,R. Riosmena-Rodriguez,M.A. Oliveira-Figueiredo
Community structure of rhodolith-forming beds on the central Brazilian continental shelf
Helgoland Mar. Res., 68 (2013), pp. 27-35
Corresponding author.
Copyright © 2016. Associação Brasileira de Ciência Ecológica e Conservação